Microsoft's ODF support is broken, says alliance

By   |  May 22, 2009

The OpenDocument Format (ODF) Alliance says that “serious deficiencies” in Microsoft’s support for ODF need to be addressed to ensure greater interoperability with other ODF-supporting software.

ODF Alliance managing director Marino Marcich said in a press statement this week that “support for ODF represents an important and ongoing test of Microsoft’s commitment to real-world interoperability. Unfortunately, serious shortcomings have been identified in Microsoft’s support for ODF. Putting potentially millions of ODF files into circulation that are non-interoperable and incompatible with the ODF support provided by other vendors is a recipe for fragmentation.”

Late last month Microsoft release Service Pack 2 for Office 2007 which provides users with the ability to open and save ODF files. However, Marcich says, an initial round of testing (PDF) of Microsoft’s support for ODF in Office 2007 revealed serious shortcomings that, “left unaddressed, would break the open standards-based interoperability that the marketplace, especially governments, was demanding”.

“A number of basic interoperability tests between Microsoft Office 2007 and various ODF-supporting software suites revealed that the level of interoperability was far short of what governments around the world are demanding,” said Marcich. “For example, even the most basic spreadsheet functions, such as adding the numbers contained in two cells, were simply stripped in an ODF file when opened and re-saved in Microsoft Office 2007. A document created in one ODF-supporting application, when re-saved in Microsoft Office 2007, rendered differently – missing bullets, page numbers, charts and other objects, changed fonts – making collaboration on an ODF file with Office 2007 very difficult. Indeed, some of the so-called ‘plug-ins’ were revealed to provide better support for ODF than the recently released Microsoft Office 2007 SP2. This is no way to achieve the interoperability around ODF that the marketplace is demanding.”

“Tracked changes are essential to document collaboration, and formulas are the essence of spreadsheets. Microsoft’s failure to support either in SP2 is revealing with regard to its support for real-world interoperability,” added Marcich. “Given the shortcomings in Microsoft’s support for ODF, governments need to continue to demand that Microsoft implement support in a manner that plays well with the software of other vendors.” Despite these concerns, Marcich cited the growing interest in ODF. “The intense, widespread interest in Microsoft’s support for ODF suggests the public debate over document formats is not about to end anytime soon,” concluded Marcich. “What is clear is that the era of public information being locked in a closed format requiring the public to purchase a particular brand of software is rapidly coming to a close, thanks in no small measure to the courage and foresight of leading ODF-supporting governments that have been willing to take a stand on this important public-policy issue.

Comments

5 Responses to “Microsoft's ODF support is broken, says alliance”

  1. patrick saunders
    May 22nd, 2009 @ 11:51 am

    Did you expect anything else? Microsoft’s intention has always been to break ODF. Their fast tracked ISO fiasco in which they bribed key officials and forced the organisation to stifle legitimate dissent is testimony to this. The only way to fight them is to force government to completely abandon MS in favour of ODF with absolutely no exception. I think I stand a better chance of falling pregnant, though.

  2. Matt Boehm
    May 22nd, 2009 @ 11:23 pm

    Give them a break. Look at how hard it’s been for them to implement the HTML spec faithfully in IE. Obviously they’ve got a glut in talent there.

    Plus access to conformatnt software is hard too. It’s not like they can just download OpenOffice.org.

    Oh wait…

  3. Linux News from Linux Loop » Blog Archive » Microsoft And ODF: Bad For Everyone
    May 23rd, 2009 @ 4:30 am

    […] shocking news, Microsoft’s support of ODF in Microsoft Office is basically unusable in many respects, according to the OpenDocument Format Alliance. This is a real problem for […]

  4. Matt Parry
    May 23rd, 2009 @ 8:39 am

    Microsoft could have been at the forefront of Information Technology, they could have pushed forward A.I, nanobot technology, medical research. Instead they have squandered that chance by stifling, corrupting, buying off and FUD’ing everybody else.

    This is just the beginning of the downfall for MS, they cannot even implement a ‘fair’ standard. They should have used willy wonkers squirrels to write the code for ODF compatibility.

    They will suffer the death of a thousand cuts. And good riddance too for Free software will empower the renaissance of the information technology future – Go GNU.

  5. Justin Lawrence
    May 27th, 2009 @ 12:21 pm

    Besides Ballmer, I’ve been quite impressed with the Microsoft of late and had almost forgotten why they were disliked by so many. Stuff like this brings it all back.

Comments are closed